# Disagree with Xholic's read

> Record that you disagree with something in Xholic's brief (a diagnosis, a whatChanged cause, a proposed test), what you think instead and why. Add a prediction (a metric, up or down or flat, in N days) so Xholic can check later whose read was right; the track record comes back in the result. It posts nothing.

`mentor.log_override` · write

- **MCP tool:** `log_override`. Loaded by default in MCP clients.
- **REST:** `POST /v1/mentor/log-override`
- **CLI:** `xholic mentor log-override`
- **Scope:** `write`
- **Plan:** Every plan, including the trial
- **Cost:** Free.
- **Rate limit bucket:** `write`

## Input

| Field | Type | Required | Description |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| `about` | string ≤ 200 chars | Yes | What in the brief you disagree with. |
| `xholicRead` | string ≤ 600 chars | Yes | Xholic's read, in short. |
| `agentView` | string ≤ 600 chars | Yes | What you think instead. |
| `reason` | string ≤ 600 chars | Yes | The evidence for your view. |
| `prediction` | object | No | What you expect to happen if your view is right. |
| `prediction.metric` | "median_views" \\| "replies_per_post" \\| "followers" | Yes |  |
| `prediction.direction` | "up" \\| "down" \\| "flat" | Yes |  |
| `prediction.days` | integer 3–30 | Yes |  |
| `account` | string ≤ 64 chars | No | X account to act on, as @handle. Leave it out to use the connection's default account. |
| `note` | string ≤ 20000 chars | No | Optional, on any tool: one or two sentences for Xholic's shared memory about what the user just decided, asked for or said about themselves or their plans (e.g. "Dropping threads for now; focusing on replies to founders"). Every AI the user connects reads it, so they never repeat themselves. In your words, never other people's posts. Leave it out when nothing new was said. |
| `dryRun` | boolean | No | Return exactly what would happen without doing it. |
| `idempotencyKey` | string ≤ 200 chars | No | A unique key for this write. Repeating a call with the same key returns the first result instead of acting twice. |
